Public Addresses Board About Balanced Calendar
Some Cobb County residents believe the current balanced calendar provides too many one-week breaks for students.
Although it wasn’t discussed by the Cobb County Board of Education at Thursday night’s meeting, seven of the 21 community members who addressed the board during the extended public comment period discussed the current balanced calendar.
For the first time this school year, the Cobb County School District is using a balanced schedule. The calendar roughly divides the school year evenly before and after the Christmas break. A traditional calendar starts later but could force students to finish projects during the holidays.
Two citizens were for the calendar, and five citizens were against it. Connie Jackson, the president of the Cobb County Association of Educators, said she surveyed 1,000 of her constituents and 89 percent stated they liked the balanced calendar. Another citizen, Betsy Bunte, said she didn’t want the calendar changed because it would penalize parents who had already scheduled vacations based on the balanced calendar.
Kincaid Elementary fourth-grade student Carlyn Blauvelt was one of the people who spoke against the balanced calendar.
“I’m a very good student, but I find it hard to get back in the routine with so many breaks because there’s always another one around the corner,” she said.
Carlyn also told the board that she asked some of her classmates about the schedule and 17 wanted a longer summer vacation and three favored more school-year breaks, which the balanced calendar provides.
“They were saying the kids would like this schedule, but they never asked the kids about it so I thought that maybe I should at least give an opinion of what the kids think,” Carlyn told Patch during the meeting’s five-minute break after the public comment period.
Blauvelt’s mother, Katrina, addressed the board after her daughter and read off the first semester’s schedule.
“Fourteen days on, early release, seven days on, Labor Day off, nine days on, September break (with) five days off, 15 days on, early release all week, six days on, Election Day off, 13 days on, Thanksgiving week off, three weeks on and two weeks off (for Christmas break),” she said.
Sope Creek Elementary PTA Liason Kelli Evertsen said she e-mailed her calendar proposal to board members earlier this week. Her option offered only three extended breaks during the school year, with one at Thanksgiving, another during the holidays and the last in early April.
“I feel the one-week breaks are a bit excessive," said Evertsen, a mother of four children in the district and a former teacher. "I feel they don’t make people energized, they make our kids more sluggish.”
The balanced schedule is to be discussed again at the Feb. 9 work session.
Lynn Louise Wonders, LPC, RPT-S, E-RYT
6:06 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
I think it's very important to report both sides of this. I think an article interviewing kids, parents and teachers in favor of the balanced calendar and why the desire is there to keep it at least for the next two years it was planned on being in place by so many citizens. I appreciate Mr. Fowler's fair and excellent reporting on these controversial events previously and I look forward to seeing a fair and balanced article that provides kids', parents' and teachers' positions on the other side of this argument.
Vanessa
6:08 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Same school as Scott Sweeney, Same school as Ms. Holt, Georgia needs summer, and Scott Sweeney campaign manager. I wonder if there is a connection?
Jackie
6:18 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Mr. Fowler, I appreciate your reporting, but would kindly ask you to be more mindful of both sides' arguments. I assure you that if you chose my child's school in Kennesaw, you'd get a completely different report from the PTA. The teachers, parents and students overwhelmingly support the balanced calendar at my child's school. Thanks!
Robb
10:01 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Change is difficult, I realize that. Cherokee County went through this about 8 years ago. They received a lot of push and anger over the change to a balanced calendar, and now, the vast majority of constituents think it is wonderful.
If you asked my 8 year old daughter if she wanted a longer summer, she'd say Yes. Unfortunately, she does not have the capacity to associate the incredible fun we had during those breaks and the unforgettable experiences we had as a family. She just thinks summer is fun, and why wouldn't she? She doesn't remember the times she said she was bored (we do) and couldn't wait to go back.
That being said, it is fairly hard to ignore the 800lb elephant in the room. A 72% majority voted for the balanced calendar. Even allowing for a wide margin of error, that is a very clear and distinctive majority. There simply is no real way you can refute that percentage, it's just there like a big, bright, glaring sun.
I think Mr. Sweeney re-living 2009 and referencing the parents who spoke out against the traditional calendar is a gross misrepresentation. 2 current board members, Banks and Morgan both originally favored the traditional calendar until they understood the basis, and listened to their constituents. Now, bith support the balanced calendar.
I've now spoken to over 100 parents, teachers and even the girls in our troop, and while I have not kept faithful statistics, very, very few are in favor of the traditional calendar.